All Leaders

Just wondering if anyone out there is using Paycor or Paychex and if yes, how's it working for you?

Good morning Virginia:

We presently use Paychex, and I am not happy with their service.  Many times they do things that are not in our contract.  Have been looking at other companies, but have not gotten very far due to the holiday.

God blessings on your new year.

Margaret Riehle-Moeller

Hello Virgina-

We are a larger church/school with about 100 employees. We use PayCom, and have had really good results with them. This is a link to their site. Hope this helps.

Online Payroll Services | HR Payroll Software | Paycom

Thanks, everyone, for the info! It has been helpful!

Our church only has 5 employes. I use Payroll Mat software from RealBusiness Systems. It is loaded on a PC and after setting up the data on each employee it is very easy to generate pay checks and/or pay stubs, 941s, W-2 & W-3s etc. Best part it only costs about $200/yr.

Yes we use Paychex, we’ve been using them for a few years now. As long as you have it set up correctly it works wonderfully. A tad bit expensive but for the amount of work that you don’t have to do I think it’s worth it. We have seven employees and it cost about $60 a month

We researched Paycor, Paychex and MinistryWorks. MinistryWorks was less expensive after all discounts. So far it's working well, but we're in year one of use.

Greetings!

Our church started using Paycor about 3 years ago. I have been working with it for just over 2 years. We have about 38 paid staff, most of which are hourly workers. The hourly workers "punch the clock" through an app on their phones. Frequently, they have difficulty making those punches and a supervisor has to log in to the system to correct the errors.

When pay raises went into effect at the start of our fiscal year, the change was part way through a pay period. Paycor did a great job of pro-rating the days for the salaried employees. For the hourly employees, I had to review each timecard and make manual adjustments for each hourly employee.

Onboarding new employees is not a difficult task. It would be easier if we subscribed to more of Paycor's options.

By and large I am satisfied with Paycor, but I don't have much experience with other payroll companies.